If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
dog weight chart vs breed
we went to the vet for the annual checkup last week, and the vet said Manu
is fat and needs to lose weight. she said he should look more like Lola. here's a side by side for comparison (Manu is the brindle): http://groups.msn.com/culprit/dogpla...o&PhotoID=1618 note that his left rear leg is forward, blocking the total view of his tuck. anyway, Lola is pure pit bull. likely from fighting lines. she's thin, rangy, leggy, and quick as heck. yes, you can see her ribs. Manu, OTOH, is a pit mix, probably with Lab. he's thick. he has a slight fat layer under his skin, but no more than any Lab i've seen. underneath that is pure muscle. his ribs are easily palpable, and he is incredibly athletic. while he has gained 8 pounds in the last year, he's also more muscular and has more endurance. now here's the question. Manu is slightly overweight according to the weight chart on the vet's wall. shouldn't the vet take breed and body structure into account, rather than just going by the chart? or is he actually fat? i tried reducing his food, but he was so hungry, he stole from Lola's bowl, which he doesn't do otherwise. when i brought his food back up to normal (already the very lowest amount on the package instructions for his size), he stopped stealing from Lola. opinions? -kelly |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
x-posting to rpd.health...
"culprit" wrote in message ... we went to the vet for the annual checkup last week, and the vet said Manu is fat and needs to lose weight. she said he should look more like Lola. here's a side by side for comparison (Manu is the brindle): http://groups.msn.com/culprit/dogpla...o&PhotoID=1618 note that his left rear leg is forward, blocking the total view of his tuck. anyway, Lola is pure pit bull. likely from fighting lines. she's thin, rangy, leggy, and quick as heck. yes, you can see her ribs. Manu, OTOH, is a pit mix, probably with Lab. he's thick. he has a slight fat layer under his skin, but no more than any Lab i've seen. underneath that is pure muscle. his ribs are easily palpable, and he is incredibly athletic. while he has gained 8 pounds in the last year, he's also more muscular and has more endurance. now here's the question. Manu is slightly overweight according to the weight chart on the vet's wall. shouldn't the vet take breed and body structure into account, rather than just going by the chart? or is he actually fat? i tried reducing his food, but he was so hungry, he stole from Lola's bowl, which he doesn't do otherwise. when i brought his food back up to normal (already the very lowest amount on the package instructions for his size), he stopped stealing from Lola. opinions? -kelly |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 23 Mar 2005 11:42:34 -0800, "culprit"
wrote: anyway, Lola is pure pit bull. likely from fighting lines. she's thin, rangy, leggy, and quick as heck. yes, you can see her ribs. Manu, OTOH, is a pit mix, probably with Lab. he's thick. he has a slight fat layer under his skin, but no more than any Lab i've seen. underneath that is pure muscle. his ribs are easily palpable, and he is incredibly athletic. while he has gained 8 pounds in the last year, he's also more muscular and has more endurance. Why do you think he has lab in him? He looks heavier than ideal, but pictures are too hard to say (unless a top view maybe). hands on is the best gauge, more than weight (many sports figures are technically "obese", but they are clearly not fat - muscle weighs a lot and too many factors). How tall is he at the shoulder and how much does he weigh? -- Janet B www.bestfriendsdogobedience.com http://pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/bestfr...bedience/album |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"culprit" wrote:
now here's the question. Manu is slightly overweight according to the weight chart on the vet's wall. shouldn't the vet take breed and body structure into account, rather than just going by the chart? or is he actually fat? He could probably lose a few. Don't necessarily blame the Lab in him -- Duke's (mostly) Lab and still has a tuckup and waist. Loose skin, sure, but a definite tuck. (I've really got to get some pics of the Big Black Dog soon!) Manu might never get that nice, tight tummy that Lola has, but he could probably get a little more buff and be the better for it. i tried reducing his food, but he was so hungry, he stole from Lola's bowl, which he doesn't do otherwise. when i brought his food back up to normal (already the very lowest amount on the package instructions for his size), he stopped stealing from Lola. Replace half his food with canned pumpkin (NOT pie filling!) or green beans. Or raw carrots. -- Mary H. and the Ames National Zoo: Raise A Fund, ANZ Babylon Ranger, ANZ MarmaDUKE, and Rotund Rhia |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 23 Mar 2005 11:42:34 -0800 culprit whittled these words:
we went to the vet for the annual checkup last week, and the vet said Manu is fat and needs to lose weight. Since most vets are reluctant to tell that to owners this is a good sign. Manu, OTOH, is a pit mix, probably with Lab. he's thick. he has a slight fat layer under his skin, but no more than any Lab i've seen. 90% of labs I see are obese, not just a little overweight. underneath that is pure muscle. his ribs are easily palpable, Its a bit more than that - its easier to have someone show you by comparison. and he is incredibly athletic. while he has gained 8 pounds in the last year, he's also more muscular and has more endurance. Good! now here's the question. Manu is slightly overweight according to the weight chart on the vet's wall. shouldn't the vet take breed and body structure into account, rather than just going by the chart? or is he actually fat? Of course body structure comes into it. a 22 inch fit Border collie is going to weigh about 30 pounds less than a 22 inch fit Rottweiler. i tried reducing his food, but he was so hungry, he stole from Lola's bowl, which he doesn't do otherwise. when i brought his food back up to normal (already the very lowest amount on the package instructions for his size), he stopped stealing from Lola. opinions? First determine what his current calorie intake is. If you can't get calorie figures from the bag check the manufacturer web site. Then consider adjusting the food to increase fat and protein while reducing total calories by about 10% To make the food more satisfing consider adding pumpkin or green beans don't forget to count those calories. Also feeding in a kong or buster cube will often help. -- Diane Blackman http://dog-play.com/ http://dogplay.com/Shop/ |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Janet B" wrote in message ... Why do you think he has lab in him? ] there are several factors... he has a thick, double coat that sheds rain well, a pure bred pit's single coat isn't nearly as thick and doesn't shed water as well. his ears are lower set, larger and not as soft or flexible as pit bull ears. his tail is much too thick. his nose looks more Lab than pit bull. he has a very Lab-like brisket, and he has much thicker skin than a pit. here's a good ear shot: http://groups.msn.com/culprit/manu.m...o&PhotoID=1290 and here's a head profile: http://groups.msn.com/culprit/manu.m...o&PhotoID=1422 honestly, we don't know what he's mixed with, but pit/Lab mixes are incredibly common here, so it seemed like the best fit. He looks heavier than ideal, but pictures are too hard to say (unless a top view maybe). hands on is the best gauge, more than weight (many sports figures are technically "obese", but they are clearly not fat - muscle weighs a lot and too many factors). How tall is he at the shoulder and how much does he weigh? he's about 22" and 80 pounds. -kelly |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
"Mary Healey" wrote in message . 4... He could probably lose a few. Don't necessarily blame the Lab in him -- Duke's (mostly) Lab and still has a tuckup and waist. Loose skin, sure, but a definite tuck. (I've really got to get some pics of the Big Black Dog soon!) a lot of of the Labs i see around here are the "show" type, which seem a bit heavier and have less tuck than the field variety, AFAIK. i think that's where i get my mental picture of a Lab. Replace half his food with canned pumpkin (NOT pie filling!) or green beans. Or raw carrots. we tried the green beans, and he *hated* them. it was the first time i've ever seen him hesitate around food. he ate his kibble around them. :-) he does love carrots though, so i'll try those next. thanks! -kelly |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
culprit said in rec.pets.dogs.breeds:
Replace half his food with canned pumpkin (NOT pie filling!) or green beans. Or raw carrots. we tried the green beans, and he *hated* them. How did you serve them? Dogs seem to like the french cut (shoestring) type, served frozen straight out of the bag. I just throw them on top of the regular food. it was the first time i've ever seen him hesitate around food. he ate his kibble around them. :-) he does love carrots though, so i'll try those next. And don't forget the pumpkin - it seems to stink just right for most dogs to find it irresistible. -- --Matt. Rocky's a Dog. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
culprit wrote: anyway, Lola is pure pit bull. likely from fighting lines. she's thin, rangy, leggy, and quick as heck. yes, you can see her ribs. Sorry, but in the picture Lola doesn't look thin or leggy. She looks fit. I do not see ribs in the photo. To me Lola looks in perfect condition, not thin. Manu, OTOH, is a pit mix, probably with Lab. he's thick. he has a slight fat layer under his skin, but no more than any Lab i've seen. underneath that is pure muscle. his ribs are easily palpable, and he is incredibly athletic. while he has gained 8 pounds in the last year, he's also more muscular and has more endurance. Manu looks heavy to me. Even without his leg forward his tuckup would be minimal. He looks to me like he's got a bit of fat pad over his hips and around the front of his shoulders/brisket. Generally, muscle doesn't build up around the tops of shoulder, top of the back, tuckup, waist, or brisket. Muscle builds in the side of the shoulder and hindquarters. I think he's at least that 8 pounds too heavy. now here's the question. Manu is slightly overweight according to the weight chart on the vet's wall. Frankly I think the weight charts err on the side of the pet owner that's used to fat dogs. In other words, what the vet chart calls "perfect" I call borderline overweight. S shouldn't the vet take breed and body structure into account, rather than just going by the chart? or is he actually fat? Sorry.... i tried reducing his food, but he was so hungry, he stole from Lola's bowl, which he doesn't do otherwise. when i brought his food back up to normal (already the very lowest amount on the package instructions for his size), he stopped stealing from Lola. First, stop free feeding them or feeding them where they can steal each others food. Bad idea. Second, ignore the instructions on the back of the dog food bag. They ALWAYS recommend feeding way too much food for the size of dog. And don't think "Oh, I have to feed him more because he's hungry." Feed him what it takes to keep him fit. If you want, buy some canned pumpkin and feed it along with the food. I think you want Manu to look more like Lola. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Sorry, but in the picture Lola doesn't look thin or leggy. She looks fit. I do not see ribs in the photo. To me Lola looks in perfect condition, not thin. i don't mean she's too thin, she's in perfect condition for her build. which is much leaner than a show AmStaff or a UKC APBT. or, potentially, a pit mix. Manu looks heavy to me. Even without his leg forward his tuckup would be minimal. He looks to me like he's got a bit of fat pad over his hips and around the front of his shoulders/brisket. Generally, muscle doesn't build up around the tops of shoulder, top of the back, tuckup, waist, or brisket. Muscle builds in the side of the shoulder and hindquarters. I think he's at least that 8 pounds too heavy. ok, that makes sense. First, stop free feeding them or feeding them where they can steal each others food. Bad idea. i don't free feed, and since they're supervised when eating, food theivery has never been an issue before. i'll move their feeding bowls to see if it helps. I think you want Manu to look more like Lola. that's what the vet thinks, but i don't think it's necessarily possible. i don't think i could get a Rottie to look like Lola. and i don't think i could get Lola to look like a Whippet. hence the different body type by breed question. thanks for the input, and i'll continue with the reduced feeding. -kelly |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Alsatian Shepalutes | Shepalutes | Dog breeds | 17 | September 17th 04 02:47 PM |
Alsatian Shepalutes | Shepalutes | Dog breeds | 30 | September 14th 04 02:17 PM |
Alsatian Shepalutes | Shepalutes | Dog breeds | 1 | September 13th 04 05:24 AM |
Alsatian Shepalutes | Shepalutes | Dog breeds | 0 | September 11th 04 10:44 PM |
Breed mix? size? weight? | QuirkySue | Dog breeds | 0 | October 27th 03 01:00 AM |